Question

Asked by Gareth Snell to Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs on 04 November 2026 — tabled under the Andy Burnham government

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, what assessment her Department has made of the cumulative cost to UK food manufacturers of Extended Producer Responsibility for packaging, Packaging Recovery Notes and the Plastic Pack

Answer

Answered by Emma Hardy (Labour)

The October 2024 Impact Assessment considered Extended Producer Responsibility for packaging costs. It was not sector specific and so did not assess the costs to food manufacturers specifically.

Verdict: AMBER (35/100)

The reply directly and honestly says that the October 2024 Impact Assessment covered Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) packaging costs but was not sector-specific and did not assess costs to food manufacturers. It does not address the cumulative cost burden, Packaging Recovery Notes, or the Plastic Packaging Tax, and it gives no figures or policy view. The question is therefore only partly answered, and the person who asked would likely need to follow up for the cumulative cost information.

How we got there

Question itemCoverageSpecificityRationale
What is the department's assessment or view of the cumulative cost to UK food manufacturers of Extended Producer Responsibility for packaging, Packaging Recovery Notes, and the Plastic Packaging Tax? Partially Addressed Direct The reply concretely states that the October 2024 Impact Assessment covered EPR packaging costs but was not sector-specific and did not assess costs to food manufacturers, which is an honest answer on the sector gap. It does not address the cumulative cost, Packaging Recovery Notes, or Plastic Packaging Tax, and gives no view or figures, so the item is only partly answered.

Feedback on this grading

Think this verdict is wrong, or that the question and answer have been mismatched? Let us know.

Submitting this needs Google reCAPTCHA to block spam, which sets cookies from google.com on your device — see our Cookies policy for details. Accept these cookies to show the form.